Inquirita

This search engine optimized spot is exclusively available for lease as your mini-site! View the services Inquirita provides. See Decatur, GA Real Estate Agents for a sample of what your spot could look like!

10 Top Real Estate Agents in Bloomington, IN for 2025

10 Top Real Estate Agents in Bloomington, IN for 2025

Looking for the best real estate agents in Bloomington, Indiana? In a city where historic homes sit just blocks from sleek new developments, finding the right real estate professional isn’t just helpful—it’s essential. Whether you’re buying your first home near the Indiana University campus, relocating from another state, selling a family property in Elm Heights, or eyeing new construction in Renwick or Eastside neighborhoods, working with a skilled agent can save you time, money, and frustration.

Bloomington’s real estate market has changed dramatically in recent years. Home values have climbed more than 50% over the past five years, driven by a tight housing inventory, steady demand from university faculty and students, and a growing remote workforce discovering the charm of southern Indiana. In 2025, the average rent remains above $1,500, and buyers are often facing multiple-offer scenarios on homes that may not even make it to public listing sites. This isn’t the kind of market where anyone can just “wing it”—you need someone who understands the local terrain, neighborhood by neighborhood, block by block.

The best agents in Bloomington don’t just show houses—they guide you through complex financial decisions, negotiate fiercely on your behalf, and bring deep insight into everything from school districts and walkability to local permitting and zoning quirks. They know when to move fast, when to wait, and how to read the market’s subtle signals that national websites overlook. Whether you’re selling an inherited home, investing in a student rental, or upgrading after a growing family, your experience depends on having a trusted advocate in your corner.

That’s why we created this list. We’ve done the legwork to bring you the most up-to-date roundup of Bloomington’s top-performing real estate agents for 2025. These professionals consistently stand out for their responsiveness, market expertise, client reviews, and proven results. No gimmicks—just agents who deliver. Whether you’re buying, selling, or investing in Bloomington, these are the names you’ll want on your shortlist.

1. Stockton MillerCentury 21 Scheetz

  • Experience: 8 years
  • Transactions: 113 sales in the last 3 years
  • Average Price Point: $442.3K
  • Total Sales Last Year: $15.6M
  • Client Feedback: Responsive, communicative, professional, knowledgeable
  • Google Rating: 5.0 stars (19 reviews)

Stockton Miller has become a trusted name in Bloomington real estate thanks to his combination of local insight and businesslike efficiency. Whether you’re relocating from out of state or buying your third home, he keeps things smooth and stress-free.

Left double quotation mark U+201C Left double quotation mark

We are in the process of buying a home with Stockton, and we can’t recommend him highly enough. We weren’t super thrilled with the realtor that we had for our first house, so we were looking for a change. I was impressed with the experience our friends had buying a home with Stockton, so we decided to give him a try. I appreciate that Stockton is quick to respond. The house we are buying is one that I knew would go fast, so I wanted to jump on it right away. Even though he was out of town that day, he coordinated with a coworker to get us a showing same day. I also like that he gives his honest opinion. I never felt like he was trying to push a house on us, and he was up front about potential issues with houses. He also respected our budget and did everything he could to get us a good deal, even though it meant that his commission would be less. We will definitely be using Stockton again next time we need a realtor!

 – Amanda Scamacca

Left double quotation mark U+201C Left double quotation mark

Stockton was very helpful when we were relocating to Bloomington from California. We had a tight timeline to work with and Stockton was up for the challenge. We met with Stockton for the first time on May 26th and we were under contract on our home by May 27th!!! Stockton has a wealth of knowledge about Bloomington and the housing market. We were able to purchase our house sight unseen due to Stockton’s willingness to do a VERY thorough walkthrough video of the home and we got lucky because the seller had an inspection done prior to listing. Stockton is organized, detail-oriented, and quick and thorough in his communication. Stockton had our backs the entire process and we are happy with our purchase and new home.

 – gayle bandy

2. Amy KoppRE/MAX Acclaimed Properties

  • Experience: 18 years
  • Transactions: 90 sales in the last 3 years
  • Average Price Point: $349.7K
  • Total Sales Last Year: $19.5M
  • Client Feedback: Professional, responsive, knowledgeable, communicative
  • Google Rating: 5.0 stars (56 reviews)

Amy Kopp is one of those agents who doesn’t just show houses—she knows neighborhoods down to the streetlight. Clients stick with her because she shows up, follows through, and gets results.

Left double quotation mark U+201C Left double quotation mark

Amy is, without a doubt, one of the most diligent, focused, and hardworking real estate professionals I have ever had the pleasure of working with. Having worked alongside her for several years, I have consistently been impressed by her unwavering commitment to her clients and her ability to navigate even the most complex transactions with ease.

Her attention to detail is unmatched—nothing slips through the cracks when Amy is involved. She takes the time to truly understand her clients' needs and works tirelessly to ensure they receive the best possible outcome. Beyond her expertise, Amy is incredibly personable and makes every interaction a positive one. She has a way of making people feel comfortable and confident throughout the buying or selling process, and that’s a rare quality in this industry.

If you’re looking for a real estate agent who is not only knowledgeable and experienced but also deeply committed to your success, Amy and her team are the ones you want by your side. I can’t recommend her highly enough!

 – Elan Edwards

Left double quotation mark U+201C Left double quotation mark

I contacted Amy after having a terrible experience with another agent. She was kind and was able to help me find a great property. As an investor she was a great fit and would provide all the information I needed in order to do analysis on rentals. She is always willing to answer any questions I have and works hard to make sure I am getting the best deal possible. I plan on using her for every property I purchase and would highly recommend her to anyone I know.

 – Seth Helton

3. Juan Carlos CarrasquelThe JuanSells.com Realty Co.

  • Experience: 21 years
  • Transactions: 82 sales in the last 3 years
  • Average Price Point: $309.8 K
  • Total Sales Last Year: $19 M
  • Client Feedback: Responsive, professional, knowledgeable, communicative
  • Google Rating: 4.8 stars (189 reviews)

A seasoned pro in the Bloomington market, Juan Carrasquel offers a full‑service experience backed by tech‑forward tools and relentless follow‑through. Clients appreciate how he keeps complicated deals on track while negotiating hard on their behalf.

Left double quotation mark U+201C Left double quotation mark

As a first-time homebuyer and an international resident, trust was crucial for me in choosing a realtor, and Juan exceeded my expectations in every way. From our first meeting, it was clear that Juan was dedicated to putting my needs first. He guided me through each step of the home-buying process with patience and expertise, making what could have been a stressful experience much easier.Juan’s in-depth knowledge and his ability to explain complex details in an understandable way were invaluable. He provided thoughtful and practical suggestions that helped me make informed decisions. He also connected me with a reliable local mortgage company and structural engineers, which helped ensure that nothing was overlooked in my new home.He kept me informed every step of the way, met all deadlines, and was always available to answer my questions, no matter how small.I would recommend Juan to anyone buying a new home, especially first-time buyers. His professionalism, trustworthiness, and genuine care for his clients make him an exceptional realtor.

 – Jeffrey Peter

Left double quotation mark U+201C Left double quotation mark

Juan helped my husband and me find our first home and truly cared about what we wanted and needed. He also made sure we got the best deal possible and kept the whole process as smooth as it could be. Thanks!!

 – Kenzie Forbes

4. Deb TomaroDeb Tomaro Real Estate

  • Experience: 18 years
  • Transactions: 96 sales in the last 3 years
  • Average Price Point: $290.7K
  • Total Sales Last Year: $18M
  • Client Feedback: Responsive, knowledgeable, professional, available remotely
  • Google Rating: 5.0 stars (6 reviews)

Deb Tomaro blends deep Bloomington knowledge with a flexible, modern approach to client service. Remote or in-person, she makes buying and selling feel manageable and even kind of fun.

Left double quotation mark U+201C Left double quotation mark

I found Deb through the Home Buyer’s class through HAND, and I could not have been luckier that she was the realtor for the class! She is knowledgeable, incredibly patient, ludicrously responsive (even on evenings and weekends), and always offers great advice. She wasn’t in it just to make a sale - she really made sure I found a good home that worked for me and my needs (even advising me against a home if she knew it wouldn’t be a good fit). As a first-time home buyer, her experience, advice, and expertise were essential in my feeling comfortable to buy a home. She even recommended a loan officer (who was also AWESOME), and they actually worked together a lot, which saved me tons of back and forth. She even met with me, my loan officer, and dad to make sure everyone was on the same page. She sat through all of my and my dad’s questions, thoroughly and patiently explaining anything and everything we could want to know. She also recommended great home inspectors!Could not recommend a better realtor, especially for a first-time home buyer!

 – Alison Crutchfield

Left double quotation mark U+201C Left double quotation mark

We have worked with Deb to both sell and buy homes. She is fantastic at what she does- knowledgeable, communicative and upbeat. Deb knows the market and knows our community. She is also incredibly generous, supporting a variety of worthy area nonprofits. We highly recommend Deb!!

 – Allison Hess

5. Rebekah SimsCentury 21 Scheetz

  • Experience: 8 years
  • Transactions: 27 sales in the last 3 years
  • Average Price Point: $357.9K
  • Total Sales Last Year: $7.5M
  • Client Feedback: Communicative, professional, responsive
  • Google Rating: 5.0 stars (8 reviews)

Rebekah Sims may not shout the loudest, but her clients will tell you she delivers. With an eye for details and a strong communication style, she handles each sale with care.

Left double quotation mark U+201C Left double quotation mark

From the moment we decided to sell our home, Rebekah was there every step of the way. She worked tirelessly to ensure that our house was marketed in the best possible way, and as a result, we received multiple offers within just a few days of listing.

Rebekah’s expertise and attention to detail were evident throughout the entire process. She provided valuable insights into the local real estate market, helped us set a competitive price for our home, and even recommended some minor updates and repairs that made a huge difference in how our home showed to potential buyers.

What impressed us most, however, was her ability to navigate the negotiations with ease. She was an excellent communicator, keeping us informed at every stage of the process and making sure that all of our questions and concerns were addressed. Thanks to her guidance, we were able to close the sale of our home, for a price that exceeded our expectations.

Overall, we would highly recommend Rebekah to anyone looking to buy or sell a home. She is a true professional who goes above and beyond for her clients and has a deep understanding of the real estate market. Thank you, Rebekah, for helping us sell our home so quickly and for making the entire process so smooth and stress-free!

 – Valerie Deem

Left double quotation mark U+201C Left double quotation mark

Rebekah is extremely knowledgeable and was helpful throughout the whole process of selling our home. She was responsive and communicated very well. She made everything very easy for us and met all of our home selling needs - actually exceeding our expectations! I would highly recommend her to anyone who needs a realtor.

 – Sarah Crotzer

6. Theresa SicinskiRE/MAX Acclaimed Properties

  • Experience: 22 years
  • Transactions: 47 sales in the last 3 years
  • Average Price Point: $358.9K
  • Total Sales Last Year: $7M
  • Client Feedback: Responsive, knowledgeable, outstanding, trustworthy
  • Google Rating: 5.0 stars (5 reviews)

When you want someone steady at the wheel, Theresa Sicinski delivers. She’s guided families, downsizers, and first-timers with the same steady hand and local savvy.

Left double quotation mark U+201C Left double quotation mark

We have used Theresa Sicinski twice to buy and sell our homes. She is very knowledgeable about real estate values and does an excellent job of staging and marketing properties. Best of all, she is an outstanding problem solver. When a last minute difficulty arose just days before our closing, Theresa quickly found a way to keep our deal on track. Her meticulous attention to detail and high level of commitment to her clients make her a top tier agent.

 – Penny Gillie

Left double quotation mark U+201C Left double quotation mark

We worked with Theresa to sell our home recently, and we’re so glad she was the one there to help us. She kept us on track through a renovation and asked us questions that helped us to understand what we wanted in a new home. She was always available when we needed her and was so patient when our wants and location changed. She’s knowledgeable, friendly, and has a gift for design and staging. Knowing she was in our corner just made everything easier.

 – Teri Hruby

7. Amanda RichardsonFC Tucker Bloomington

  • Experience: 22 years
  • Transactions: 40+ in the last 3 years
  • Average Price Point: $400.1K
  • Total Sales Last Year: $15M+
  • Client Feedback: Professional, responsive, communicative, outstanding
  • Google Rating: 5.0 stars (13 reviews)

Amanda Richardson isn’t just about listings—she brings clarity and confidence to every step of the buying or selling process. It’s why so many of her clients turn into repeat customers and referrals.

Left double quotation mark U+201C Left double quotation mark

Amanda is THE BEST! She always went above and beyond! She is an 8th generation Hoosier and she is extremely knowledgeable about the area and any services or recommendations you would need. In this absolutely insane time of buying in Bloomington, we had to make an offer without seeing the home. For over a month, she responded quickly and timely and went to see homes for us. She quickly gained our trust and we were able to confidently place an offer based on her review of the home. Even after closing, if I need recommendations in the area or have questions, I reach out to her and she still responds quickly. She does not disappoint! We love our new home and we could not have done it without her!

 – Jennifer Trpkovski

Left double quotation mark U+201C Left double quotation mark

I have worked with many real estate professionals for my own purchases or sales and for my clients. Amanda is one of the best real estate agents that I have ever encountered. Not only was she knowledgeable about the area where we were searching for property, she had specific knowledge about every property that she showed, including its history. Every question that we asked was immediately answered. She had perfect referrals for every inspection. She kept the process on track without any prodding. If you are looking for property in the Unionville / Bloomington area you cannot find a better real estate professional.

 – Terry Monday

8. Tracee LutesRE/MAX Acclaimed Properties

  • Experience: 20+ years
  • Transactions: 60+ in the last 3 years
  • Average Price Point: $350K
  • Total Sales Last Year: $14.2M
  • Client Feedback: Knowledgeable, dependable, strategic, thoughtful
  • Google Rating: 4.9 stars (31 reviews)

Tracee’s deep familiarity with Bloomington housing trends makes her a consistent top performer. Buyers and sellers count on her for level-headed guidance and strong results.

Left double quotation mark U+201C Left double quotation mark

This summer my husband found himself in the position of executor for his aunt’s estate which included a house that needed cleared out and sold. The stress was overwhelming for us, but Tracee was there at every turn! The house was 3 hrs away from our home so when we went for clear out, we exhausted ourselves with weekend trips to haul things out. Tracee met us on site and helped us prepare for listing the home. She was always providing us suggestions and recommendations not only related to the sale of the home, but where items could be donated. She was supportive and calming when the task seemed insurmountable. And when the time came, she guided us through every step of the listing and showing process. Within the first hour on the market, Tracee had appointments for showings booked. Within 24 hrs she presented us with 2 offers to review. We sold the home very quickly and she even helped us by asking the new buyers if they wanted any furniture from the home. She really took weeks, days, hours off of our journey, which was a blessing, as we both work and we have a horse farm to take care of back home! I think you would be hard pressed to find a realtor better than Tracee! She is full of knowledge, compassion, and ideas all while being a professional agent! We cannot thank you enough, Tracee! Thank you for who you are and how you excel at what you do! We appreciate you so very much! We hope to never have to do this again in Monroe County, but if we find ourselves that situation… YOU are our agent!!

 – Ann

Left double quotation mark U+201C Left double quotation mark

As first time home buyers back in 2016 Tracee went to bat to us on a house that no first time homebuyer needed to step into. We worked with Tracee on a new construction build then in 2020 we listed our house and used her to purchase our current home. Tracee has her clients best interests and her communication is top notch. As long as Tracee is around we will continue to use her, she’s the best!

 – Alec Leggio

9. Ron PlecherRealty Professionals

  • Experience: 30+ years
  • Transactions: 50+ in the last 3 years
  • Average Price Point: $375K
  • Total Sales Last Year: $10M+
  • Client Feedback: Trustworthy, experienced, strategic, personable
  • Google Rating: 5.0 stars (32 reviews)

A Bloomington mainstay, Ron Plecher’s name often comes up when locals ask, “Who’s the best?” He combines decades of insight with a calm, confident approach.

Left double quotation mark U+201C Left double quotation mark

Ron is truly exceptional. I met him when I was searching for a home in Bloomington in 2015. My sister and brother-in-law recommended Ron for our home buying process, based on their excellent experience with him. I was impressed with his level of knowledge and the amount of data that they had about the market. It was a no-brainer for me to work with Ron since I was set on buying in Park Ridge East neighborhood and I’m so thankful I did. Ron was always available for home tours. His responsiveness was incredible. If they didn’t pick up, they always call back very soon. Once we found the right place, he strategically got us the place within 2 days of it being on the market with a preemptive offer! He highlighted the concerns he had about the home and the research they wanted to do to make sure progress was being made and I wouldn’t have to wait for a long time to move in.Ron also truly understands how to sell houses. When we started thinking about selling the house a few months ago, Ron helped us to find contractors to remodel it and do necessary repairs before we list it for sale. He made the process incredibly easy and his thorough knowledge, not only of general real estate, but of the local and national market made it a great pleasure throughout the whole process of selling. The delivery of the information was straightforward: present the info and talk about pros, cons, and strategy for moving forward. He really treats the situation like he’s selling his own property – he has your best interests in mind. Their cool, calm mindset kept my anxiety low and gave me the confidence he would get the job done – and he did! I’ve already recommended him to one of my good friends, and Ron helped him to sell his home as well. He’s the best realtor with a great team around him.

 – Wasantha Jayawardene

Left double quotation mark U+201C Left double quotation mark

Fantastic experience. Ron is an expert realtor who made the house buying process easy and provided great advise along the journey. I would definitely work with him again and highly recommend him to anyone looking for a realtor!

 – Braxton R

10. Lesa MillerRe/Max

  • Experience: 12 years
  • Transactions: 38+ in the last 3 years
  • Average Price Point: $340K
  • Total Sales Last Year: $8.1M
  • Client Feedback: Informed, thoughtful, consistent, great communicator
  • Google Rating: 5.0 stars (110 reviews)

Lesa Miller has carved out a niche for serving buyers and sellers who appreciate clarity and candor. Her clients trust her to keep things on track and in perspective.

Left double quotation mark U+201C Left double quotation mark

Lesa is highly responsive, able to move quickly through the home viewing and purchasing process, and helpful after closing. I bought and sold a condo with her previously and just purchased a house with her as my realtor. Both experiences went exceptionally smoothly.

I know I can trust Lesa to give me good advice, and Lesa has regularly and consistently followed up with me outside of the house buying process—she recently contacted me after Hurricane Helene because she knew I was living in East TN just to see how me and my family were doing. This was before she knew I was moving back to Bloomington and would soon be buying a house.

Overall, I would highly recommend Lesa as a realtor!

 – Cargile Williams

Left double quotation mark U+201C Left double quotation mark

I worked with Lesa Miller on finding my first home. I can’t express enough how grateful I am that she was my partner during this process. Lesa was very knowledgeable and honest with me during viewings, making offers, and landing my first home. I HIGHLY recommend using her as your realtor as she will work hard for you.

 – Kyle Lizenby